Lorelei Resort Hotel
Two-star pricing, four-and-a-half-star satisfaction — with pets welcome.
A place to stay in Treasure Island
Lorelei Resort Hotel is a 2-star property in Treasure Island, Florida, rated 4.5/5 across 163 guest reviews. That gap between the star count and the guest score is worth paying attention to. The hotel sits within easy reach of Treasure Island Beach and a solid spread of local dining. It accepts pets, which is a practical plus in a coastal town where many properties don't. For the price point and the location, it draws consistently strong feedback across nearly every category reviewers raised.
Who this stay suits
A no-frills 2-star hotel that overdelivers on cleanliness, service, and pet-friendliness in a well-connected Treasure Island location.
Best for
- Pet owners travelling with animals
- Budget-conscious Florida coast visitors
- Guests prioritising location for local exploring
- Travellers who value cleanliness over extras
Less suited to
- Travellers expecting resort-style facilities
- Those wanting on-site dining
- Visitors seeking luxury finishes
A location built for getting out
Treasure Island Beach is just over a kilometre away, and the surrounding area has restaurants, cafes, and parks within easy reach. Guests consistently flag the location as a strength — 48 of 49 location mentions in reviews were positive.
Pets are genuinely welcome here
The hotel accepts pets, and the numbers back it up: 54 of 59 pet-related review mentions were positive. That's a high hit rate for a category that often generates complaints elsewhere.
Clean rooms, consistent scores
Cleanliness scored 46 positive out of 47 mentions — about as close to unanimous as guest reviews get. The property overall ran 54 positive out of 60 mentions, with rooms adding another 17 of 20.
Kitchens guests actually use
Kitchen facilities drew 18 positive mentions out of 18 total — a perfect record. For guests who'd rather cook than eat out every night, this is a practical reason to choose Lorelei over a standard room-only property.
On the map
Things to do nearby
- Treasure Island Beach park 1.05 km
- Golf Creek Park park 2.44 km
Where to eat
- Subway fast food 0.19 km
- Little Dog House fast food 0.66 km
- Treasure Bay Resort and Marina restaurant 0.91 km
- Nina's Cafe On the Beach cafe 1.16 km
- Shrimpys Blues Bistro restaurant 1.18 km
- Carino's Northern Italian Cuisine restaurant 1.2 km
Across 163 reviews, the property scores 4.5/5. Location is the standout — 48 of 49 mentions positive. Cleanliness and kitchens both approach perfect marks. Service, pets, and the property overall each log roughly 90% positive rates. Rooms score 17 of 20. Nature-related mentions — likely the coastal surroundings — run 37 of 43.
- Things to do4.3
- Restaurants3.8
- Public transit3.6
- Airport access3.5
Share of positive mentions per theme, from Google reviews.
Good to know
Frequently asked
Is the hotel pet-friendly?
Yes. Pets are accepted, and guest feedback on the experience is strongly positive — 54 of 59 pet-related review mentions were favourable. It's one of the more consistently praised aspects of the property.
How close is Treasure Island Beach?
Treasure Island Beach is approximately 1.05 km from the hotel — a walkable distance for most guests, depending on your pace and the Florida heat.
What dining options are nearby?
There are several options within about 1.2 km: Shrimpys Blues Bistro, Carino's Northern Italian Cuisine, Nina's Cafe On the Beach, and Treasure Bay Resort and Marina restaurant. A Subway is 0.19 km away for quick meals.
Do rooms have kitchen facilities?
Kitchen facilities are available and guests rate them highly — all 18 kitchen-related review mentions were positive. This makes the property practical for self-catering stays.
What is the guest rating?
The hotel holds a 4.5/5 rating based on 163 guest reviews. That's a strong result for a 2-star property and reflects consistently positive feedback across location, cleanliness, service, and rooms.
What is the hotel's star rating?
Lorelei Resort Hotel is a 2-star property. Despite that, guest satisfaction consistently runs well above what the star count might suggest.
Is the area good for things to do?
Yes — 'things to do' is a noted location strength. The beach, parks, and a range of local restaurants are all reachable within a couple of kilometres.
How is the service rated by guests?
Service drew 44 positive mentions out of 50 total in guest reviews — a solid 88% positive rate, consistent with the hotel's overall high satisfaction scores.
Is Golf Creek Park nearby?
Yes. Golf Creek Park is approximately 2.44 km from the hotel — a short drive or a longer walk.
How do I book?
The hotel can be booked through your preferred travel platform or by contacting the property directly. No published rates are available through this guide — check current pricing at the time of booking.